Health Insurance Is Getting More Expensive. Here’s What to Compare Besides the Monthly Premium
COST & COVERAGE · 5 MIN READ
When most people compare health insurance, they start in exactly the same place:
“How much is it per month?”
It's an important question.
It just shouldn't be the only one.
A $450-per-month plan isn't necessarily less expensive than a $550-per-month plan once you actually start using healthcare.
That's because your premium buys access to a benefit structure and that structure determines how costs are divided between you and the insurance plan throughout the year.
With healthcare costs continuing to rise, understanding that structure matters more than ever.
Think beyond the sticker price
Imagine two plans.
One costs $500 per month.
Another costs $600.
At first glance, the first plan saves you $1,200 per year.
Easy decision, right?
Not necessarily.
What if the $500 plan carries a substantially higher deductible, higher specialist costs or a network that doesn't include the hospital system you prefer?
Suddenly, that $100 monthly savings doesn't tell the whole story.
Here are the numbers I'd examine before deciding which plan is actually more affordable.
1. Deductible
Your deductible is the amount you generally must pay toward certain covered services before your plan begins sharing those costs.
But there's another question that matters:
What actually applies to it?
Some plans provide certain services before you've satisfied the full deductible. Others subject considerably more care to it.
That's why comparing two plans simply by saying “this one has a $5,000 deductible” can be misleading.
Look at how the deductible interacts with the benefits you are most likely to use.
2. Copays
Copays can make routine healthcare more predictable.
Depending on the plan, you might see a fixed amount for things such as:
Primary care
Specialist visits
Urgent care
Prescription medications
But don't assume a copay automatically applies.
A service might instead be subject to the deductible, coinsurance or another cost-sharing arrangement.
Your Summary of Benefits and Coverage and other plan documents can help clarify how those services are treated.
3. Coinsurance
Coinsurance is usually expressed as a percentage.
For example, after satisfying an applicable deductible, your plan might pay 80% of the allowed cost of a covered service while you pay 20%.
Twenty percent doesn't sound particularly intimidating until you attach it to an expensive procedure.
That's why percentages matter.
When comparing plans, determine when coinsurance applies and what ultimately limits your exposure.
4. Out-of-pocket maximum
This is one of the numbers I want consumers to understand before enrolling.
For ACA-compliant major medical coverage, the out-of-pocket maximum limits what you pay for covered in-network essential health benefits during the plan year, although premiums and certain other expenses do not count toward it.
Think about your health insurance from two directions:
What does it cost me if very little happens?
and
What could it cost me if something major happens?
Both matter.
5. Provider network
Cost doesn't mean much if you can't conveniently access the care you want.
Look beyond the insurance carrier's logo.
Two plans from the same insurance company can use different provider networks.
Check your:
Doctors. Specialists. Hospitals. Urgent care facilities. Pharmacies.
And if you travel frequently or live in more than one state, understand how your plan handles care outside your local service area.
6. Prescription benefits
If anyone in your household regularly takes medication, prescription coverage deserves its own review.
Check the formulary.
Look at tiers.
Understand prior authorization requirements.
And determine whether your medications are subject to copays, coinsurance or the deductible.
So which plan is actually cheaper?
There isn't a universal answer.
The cheapest plan for someone who rarely uses healthcare may be completely different from the cheapest plan for someone who regularly sees specialists, takes several medications or anticipates a procedure.
That's why I prefer a different question:
What does this plan make financially predictable?
A strong health insurance decision balances the premium you can comfortably afford today with the financial exposure you could reasonably handle tomorrow.
Sometimes paying more in premium for a different benefit structure makes sense.
Sometimes it doesn't.
The important part is knowing the trade-off before something happens.
Affordable today and affordable when you need care aren't always the same thing.
At Elite Health Preserve, we help consumers compare more than a monthly price. We look at benefits, networks, cost-sharing and your actual healthcare priorities.
Comments